Sweet Tomatoes Pizza

★★★★☆
  • 1279 Washington St

    West Newton, MA 02465

    Map & Directions
  • 617-630-8666

Food

Food
More choices in West Newton:
Resultset_next

Pizza King Station

7045 Bluff Rd Indianapolis, IN

Resultset_next

Pasquale's Pizza & Carry Out

1135 E Troy Ave Indianapolis, IN

4.0 8
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Sweet Tomatoes Pizza was?
Write a Review
.

Sweet Tomatoes Pizza is easily the best pizza in Newton. This was the first pizza that I ate after moving to Newton, and no other pizza has even come close. It may seem obvious from their name, but their tomato sauce is absolutely amazing with large, delicious chunks of tomatoes. I would also recommend their cheese calzone.

Unfortunately this location doesn't deliver, and the selection is somewhat limited if you're looking for anything other than pizza. But it still gets 5 stars for the amazing pizza!

5
★★★★★

Sweet Tomatoes Pizza is easily the best pizza in Newton. This was the first pizza that I ate after moving to Newton, and no other pizza has even come close. It may seem obvious from their name, but their tomato sauce is absolutely amazing with large, delicious chunks of tomatoes. I would also recommend their cheese calzone.

Unfortunately this location doesn't deliver, and the selection is somewhat limited if you're looking for anything other than pizza. But it still gets 5 stars for the amazing pizza!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

My favorite pizza hands down. Expensive, but worth it when you're craving it. Thin pizza is not easy to find. When I find it, I cherish it. Best pizza in Newton. No question.

5
★★★★★

My favorite pizza hands down. Expensive, but worth it when you're craving it. Thin pizza is not easy to find. When I find it, I cherish it. Best pizza in Newton. No question.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I would give it five stars, but my husband isn't a fan. It is a bit on the pricey side and you have to like unique pizza flavors. I love the pesto pizza! Lunchtime is great because there is always a "slice of the day" available. Some of the flavors are better than others, but that's why God invented the basic cheese pizza! Enjoy!

4
★★★★☆

I would give it five stars, but my husband isn't a fan. It is a bit on the pricey side and you have to like unique pizza flavors. I love the pesto pizza! Lunchtime is great because there is always a "slice of the day" available. Some of the flavors are better than others, but that's why God invented the basic cheese pizza! Enjoy!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Aside from Pizzeria Regina in the "North End" and a few, true spots in the North burbs, this is as good as it gets for real Neapolitan style pizza, 200 mile northeast of Brooklyn. Famous Rays NY it ain't. However, it is not that greasy pan style pizza that is pawned off by Greek sub shop owners from Maine to RI. New England aside of the Italian enclaves is not known for pizza. This however, ever is good stuff, wood fired pizza ovens with a crispy crusts and hand kneaded dough...just they way momma used to make. Enjoy. Topping's are varied and all good but remember this is thin style mainland Italian style and it's really only made to support perhaps cheese and tomato sauce, try adding a mushroom or pepperoni only...otherwise it will fall apart. Mangi

2
★★★★☆

Aside from Pizzeria Regina in the "North End" and a few, true spots in the North burbs, this is as good as it gets for real Neapolitan style pizza, 200 mile northeast of Brooklyn. Famous Rays NY it ain't. However, it is not that greasy pan style pizza that is pawned off by Greek sub shop owners from Maine to RI. New England aside of the Italian enclaves is not known for pizza. This however, ever is good stuff, wood fired pizza ovens with a crispy crusts and hand kneaded dough...just they way momma used to make. Enjoy. Topping's are varied and all good but remember this is thin style mainland Italian style and it's really only made to support perhaps cheese and tomato sauce, try adding a mushroom or pepperoni only...otherwise it will fall apart. Mangi

Pros: the pizza crust

Cons: small seating area - best to take out

.

I tried this place out and thought that it was ok. It was definitely better than your mom and pop places, but I was disappointed when I ordered their veggie pizza, and the dough fell apart all through the middle of the pizza. The toppings were good, but I think that they must have been running out of things, as the toppings were very, very sparse. Overall, ok. Probably wouldnt recommend it, though.

0
★☆☆☆☆

I tried this place out and thought that it was ok. It was definitely better than your mom and pop places, but I was disappointed when I ordered their veggie pizza, and the dough fell apart all through the middle of the pizza. The toppings were good, but I think that they must have been running out of things, as the toppings were very, very sparse. Overall, ok. Probably wouldnt recommend it, though.

Pros: Better than mom and pop places.

Cons: Soggy crust.

.

A great pizza joint! I stopped by for a pie after work one day and I plan on making it a regular thing. It shouldn't come as news to anyone that the Boston area is hard-up for good pizza. Of course, Upper Crust is clearly the exception that proves the rule, and I must disagree with a previous reviewer who ranked ST's above UC in quality. Though I've only been to ST once, it's safe to say that UC's pizza is clearly superior both in quality of ingredients and execution. ST's is however by far the better bargain, with an 18 inch pizza starting at just around 16 bucks. The pizza also seem to be pretty healthy as pizza goes, with a light sauce and non-oily dough.

overall ST's is a very good pizza joint and an exceptional value. take a break from UC and give them a try.

2
★★★★☆

A great pizza joint! I stopped by for a pie after work one day and I plan on making it a regular thing. It shouldn't come as news to anyone that the Boston area is hard-up for good pizza. Of course, Upper Crust is clearly the exception that proves the rule, and I must disagree with a previous reviewer who ranked ST's above UC in quality. Though I've only been to ST once, it's safe to say that UC's pizza is clearly superior both in quality of ingredients and execution. ST's is however by far the better bargain, with an 18 inch pizza starting at just around 16 bucks. The pizza also seem to be pretty healthy as pizza goes, with a light sauce and non-oily dough.

overall ST's is a very good pizza joint and an exceptional value. take a break from UC and give them a try.

Pros: price, portions, freshness

Cons: small selection of specialty pizzas

.

The best pizza in Boston Resides At sweet tomatoes. they put time and effort into what they do. I tried upper crust and it cant compete

Try the 3 cheese white pizza

2
★★★★★

The best pizza in Boston Resides At sweet tomatoes. they put time and effort into what they do. I tried upper crust and it cant compete

Try the 3 cheese white pizza

Pros: Fresh Ingredients

Cons: No Delivery

.

The new location of Sweet Tomatoes offers one importand feature - more space. The same great pies are dished out here as in Newton Center, from the ordinary to to the extraordinary.
I'd recommend asking for a pie 'well done' for some extra crispy crust - especially during the pizza rush hour! ST's can be mobbed, so be prepared to wait on occasion.

2
★★★★☆

The new location of Sweet Tomatoes offers one importand feature - more space. The same great pies are dished out here as in Newton Center, from the ordinary to to the extraordinary.
I'd recommend asking for a pie 'well done' for some extra crispy crust - especially during the pizza rush hour! ST's can be mobbed, so be prepared to wait on occasion.

Pros: great pizza

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Sweet Tomatoes Pizza, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review