Boston Style Pizza at Merion
It looks like nothing special from the outside, but it's a must try for pizza. I'm an SJU alumni and I'd go here randomly for a quick & affordable bite. Must try if you're into some good pizza.
Michael's Italian Restaurant & Deli
I used to not be a fan of their pizza, but I've tried it recently and it's delicious! I love the veggie pizza. My favorite on the menu is still the grilled chicken salad. They make it with mozerella and roasted red peppers...yummmm. I'd opt for delivery or sitting in though.
Shear Waves
My grandmom has been going to Shear Waves for years now, and they really do a fabulous job on her hair. She gets it permed and colored, and she refuses to go anywhere else. They are also very kind to her -- know her name, ask her if she'd like a drink, take & hang her jacket for her, and even call her a cab afterward if she doesn't already have a ride home. The service is really excellent. I also have gotten my hair cut there twice before, and again -- I can't rave enough about the excellent service!
Redstone American Grill
Really like the atmosphere of this restaurant -- especially the outside seating during the summer. It's located in the center of a parking lot to the mall, but you immediately feel like you're on vacation once you sit outside there! I really enjoyed the flatbread pizza (reasonably priced) -- if you can spend more money, try their steaks.
Galley Beach
I went here to celebrate a birthday, and it was really wonderful. This restaurant is located right on the beach with fantastic views so make reservations to check out the sunset! It's very expensive, but that should be expected for a fine dining experience.
Stubbys
This is a bar & grille type restaurant -- I've been here for lunch and didn't think there was a huge selection, but I do like the atmosphere at night. Try the fish bowl (it's a drink) if you're brave enough... and have at least 4 people to help you!
Juice Bar
This is a famous ice-cream place on the island, and because of that it becomes PACKED (always seems to have a long line). Must try the crantucket ice cream!!
American Seasons
This place really is fantastic for a wide variety of food. I never get bored coming here! The menu seems to change a lot, but I always enjoy the fish platters (scallops are my favorite).
Fog Island Cafe
Diner atmosphere. This place has great food for breakfast, I like the breakfast burritos. Be prepared to wait about 15 minutes, it can get packed. Doesn't feel too overcrowded though even if it is packed.
Sconset Caf������
Quaint cafe and very reasonable prices -- go here for a light lunch (salads/sandwiches) and bring your own bottle of wine, too. It's BYOB, which is rare for the island.